Step five of five
Selecting the market system
How do you decide what market system is the most important for your target group?
Assess each market for its potential to:
- Affect large numbers of poor people
- Increase the poor's performance in markets, or improve their access to basic services
- Stimulate systems-level change
To understand your target group and their context, experienced practitioners recommend speaking to many market actors and consulting with a wide range of stakeholders. Different criteria for selecting your market exists in various studies. The M4P Operational Guide's three criteria, for example, are:
- relevance: whether there are poor people working or consuming goods in the market
- opportunity: opportunities for pro-poor change within the market context
- feasibility: the likelihood of success in the current social and political climate
This criteria can be used in a detailed table of questions, which can be used to assess individual market systems or to compare different market systems, using transparent ranking, such as a ‘traffic light’ scheme.
M4P Operational Guide. Chapter 1 - Strategy
Initial steps for setting programme strategy to guide analysis and action.
Action for Enterprise suggests similar criteria with an emphasis on more conventional value chain considerations such as market demand and the presence of 'forward' and 'backward' contract linkages between enterprises at all levels of the supply chain.
Information gathering and analysis to facilitate selection of value chains
Action for Enterprise template to gather information to select a value chain.
Practical Action's Participatory Market Systems Development (PMSD) Roadmap's additional criteria includes: gender equity, social inclusion, and environmental considerations. The Roadmap also suggests making decisions with strategic considerations in mind, such as potential funding sources and organisational priorities.
PMSD: Market system selection
How to select market systems(s) to focus on.
Selecting your market system is an iterative process. Market systems are complex and dynamics can and do change quickly. If one market meets a reasonable set of criteria, it may still not be feasible to work in even after a few years of implementation. Re-engage in the selection process throughout the implementation cycle so your team can continue to focus on the root causes of market failure.
VCD Wiki: Value chain selection
Online guide to USAID's approach to selecting value chains.